Longtime ExxonMobil CEO Rex Tillerson,carti erotice President-elect Donald J. Trump's secretary of state nominee, misled the Senate Foreign Relations Committee when he presented his take on climate change during a hearing Wednesday.
During the first morning of his confirmation hearings, Tillerson was pressed for his views on global warming, after bobbing and weaving around questions focused on Exxon's past research and disinformation campaign around the topic.
SEE ALSO: Climate activists protested Rex Tillerson’s nomination in T. Rex costumes“The risk of climate change does exist and the consequences of it could be serious enough that action should be taken," Tillerson told the panel. He noted that the most disagreement concerns what those actions should be.
So far, so good.
When pressed further, however, Tillerson said the following: “The increase in the greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere are having an effect, our ability to predict that effect is very limited.”
It's the second part of that sentence where Tillerson runs into a whole heap of trouble.
Don't trust my word for it, though.
Climate scientists contacted by Mashablestrongly disagreed with the assertion that the climate community is unable to foresee the likely consequences of global warming.
"To say that we don't understand the impacts or effects that a given scenario or amount of continued fossil fuel use will have on our planet was a correct statement to make in the 1800s," said Texas Tech University climate scientist Katharine Hayhoe, in an email to Mashable.
"In 2017? Not so much."
"Projections of the climate impacts associated with a given scenario, pathway, or amount of emissions... are based on physics and chemistry, the fundamentals of which have been understood since the work of [John] Tyndall and [Eunice] Foote in the 1850s," she said.
"This physics and chemistry was then used by [Svante] Arrhenius in the 1890s to make the first projections, not predictions, of how much the world would warm, if carbon dioxide levels doubled or tripled."
Michael Mann, who directs the Earth Systems Science Center at Penn State University, went further, calling Tillerson's statement "indefensible."
"It is the overwhelming consensus of the world’s scientists that our the burning of fossil fuels is not just having 'an effect,' but (a) is most likely responsible for all of the warming we have seen over the past half century and (b) is already having damaging impacts on all sectors of our economy," Mann said in an email to Mashable.
"Moreover, our ability to project future warming is not 'very limited,'" he said.
"If anything, uncertainty is breaking against us, not with us"
"Climate models have proven extremely skillful in predicting the warming that has already been observed and, by many measures (e.g. Arctic sea ice loss, melting of the major ice sheets) it is proceeding faster than climate models predicted," he added.
"If anything, uncertainty is breaking against us, not with us, which belies Tillerson’s implications to the contrary."
Tillerson made his statements shortly before NASA is expected to announce that 2016 was the warmest year on record, beating the previous benchmark set in 2015. The past year was the warmest on record in the Arctic, where sea ice hit new lows (and remain at or near record lows early in 2017).
David Titley, the director of the Center for Solutions to Weather and Climate Risk at Penn State who previously led the U.S. Navy's climate change task force, also found Tillerson's skepticism about climate science's predictive capabilities to be problematic.
Via Giphy"The ability of climate scientists to predict the future is significantly more skillful than many other professions (economics, intelligence, political science) who try and predict the future," he said in an email. "When viewed from a risk management perspective, climate science has given plenty of useful, actionable information for decision-makers to use for many years."
"...While Tillerson’s statement may be technically correct for small spatial scales and small timescales, it is very misleading in the sense of what climate models and climate scientists can and do [to] inform policy makers about future projections."
Titley said it's possible that Tillerson has confused predictions, such as short-term weather forecasts, with projections. Climate science produces the latter, based on scenarios of carbon emissions, human population growth and other factors.
"Either Tillerson doesn’t understand the difference between a climate projection and a weather prediction," Titley said, "Or he’s not-by-chance conflating the two when [he] says we 'can’t predict' the climate effect."
"I’d give him the benefit of the doubt that he hasn’t been briefed on the difference between 'prediction' and 'projection.' But maybe I’m being overly generous," he added.
Tillerson's comments are in line with Exxon's public positions under his leadership, during which time the company officially acknowledged the reality of human-caused climate change and publicly supported the Paris Climate Agreement, which seeks to limit global warming to under 2 degrees Celsius, or 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit, above preindustrial levels
Exxon has lagged far behind other oil companies, such as Total and Shell, in investing in renewables and planning for a future in which oil and gas can't be burned due to policies aimed at slashing emissions. Instead, the company has conservatively projected that virtually all of its oil and gas reserves will one day be burned.
In other words, Exxon may theoretically back the Paris agreement, but in practice it is planning for a future in which warming will be far greater than that, thereby rendering its support for the agreement largely meaningless. It is doing so in part by citing scientific and policy uncertainty, as Tillerson did on Wednesday.
If the Senate, as expected, confirms Tillerson's nomination, he will be the diplomat in charge of steering U.S. climate negotiations under the Paris treaty.
Topics Donald Trump Politics Senate
Extreme climate change suffocated ocean life 250 million years agoNFL fans lose it after Dolphins upend Patriots with a wild trick playMiles Teller apologizes to the internet for his terrifying bleached hairHow to make your Instagram 'Top Nine' for 2018Even Trump seemed to defend Obama after the president of the Philippines insulted himBow down to Aurora, fluffy cat princess and IRL Snapchat filterLyft beats rival Uber in race to file for IPOA bizarre Instagram glitch is the reason your feed is messed up'Fortnite' streamer charged after alleged domestic assault on TwitchAre wool sneakers the future of footwear? Some investors think so.Zendaya claims a cashier refused her money because of her 'skin tone'BTS member teases possible collab with Ed Sheeran, goes massively viralCows casually stroll through a woman's front yard in ScotlandPatent shows AirPods may get biometric improvements, noise cancelingThe best TV episodes of 2018Golden Globes 2019: Check out the full list of nomineesAllo, goodbye: Google is killing off the messaging appLyft beats rival Uber in race to file for IPOThis Instagram artist's mock selfThis may be the most brutally effective Facebook prank of all time The test that Trump keeps bragging about acing isn't meant to be hard Dressed for Art by Jean 6 things the White House is doing to rein in AI 69 ways to say you're horny Marco Rubio's John Lewis tribute gaffe is savagely mocked Sir Ian McKellen recorded a very sweet video for Sir Patrick Stewart's 80th birthday 'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for May 7 At the Gettin' Place by Aaron Gilbreath 'Quordle' today: See each 'Quordle' answer and hints for May 8 Staff Picks: ‘At Last,’ Ambivalence by The Paris Review Design for Living by Elaine Blair Apple Weather app down for some users again. What we know Staff Picks: Murdock Pemberton, ‘The Last September’ by The Paris Review Adam Johnson on ‘The Orphan Master’s Son’ by Karan Mahajan Getting in the Habit by Perrin Drumm Scammers hack verified Facebook pages to impersonate Meta Slave trader statue gets replaced by sculpture of Black Lives Matter protester The Epigraph by David Parker Selected Letters of William S. Burroughs by William Burroughs The Land Ark of Los Angeles by Lizzie Wade
1.3641s , 10219.0234375 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【carti erotice】,Co-creation Information Network